Table of Contents
In the high-octane atmosphere of the IPL 2025, where emotions run high and performances are scrutinized under a microscope, even a celebration can become the centre of controversy. That’s precisely what has happened with Lucknow Super Giants’ (LSG) young spinner, Digvesh Rathi. Known for his quirky ‘notebook celebration’ – mimicking the act of writing notes after dismissing a batter – Rathi has become a talking point not only for his impressive on-field performances but also for the penalties that have followed his celebrations.
During LSG’s recent clash against Kolkata Knight Riders (KKR) in IPL 2025, Rathi brought back a milder version of his iconic celebration after dismissing Sunil Narine, one of his idols. But despite its toned-down nature, the incident has reignited debates about fairness and consistency in the enforcement of the league’s code of conduct. Among those speaking out is former New Zealand fast bowler and cricket pundit Simon Doull, who hasn’t minced words in criticizing the BCCI for what he perceives as glaring double standards.
Digvesh Rathi’s notebook celebration returns again with a twist
The original ‘notebook celebration’ — Rathi pretending to jot down notes in his palm after taking a wicket — was playful and unique, capturing the imagination of fans. It was first seen when he dismissed his friend Priyansh Arya, and at the time, it was widely viewed as harmless fun. However, match officials thought otherwise, and Rathi was soon fined for what was deemed an over-the-top gesture.
Fast-forward to the LSG vs KKR encounter, and Rathi offered a reimagined version of the act — this time, writing on the floor instead of his palm. The symbolic act after dismissing Narine might have been subtler, but it didn’t escape attention. While the match referees didn’t impose a new penalty, the controversy continued to simmer.
Despite the scrutiny, Rathi’s performances have spoken volumes. With 7 wickets in five matches this season, he’s proving his mettle as a dependable bowler, all while navigating the pressures of media attention and disciplinary warnings.
Lucknow Super Giants stand by their spinner
Rathi hasn’t had to weather the storm alone. His teammates have publicly supported him, reaffirming the harmless and humorous intent behind the celebration. Shahbaz Ahmed, in an LSG social media video ahead of the match, offered insights into the context: “Priyansh Arya is his very good friend… he did it on a friendly note, but since he is on the verge of suspension, I hope he doesn’t repeat it.”
Such comments reflect the camaraderie and light-heartedness within the team. But they also highlight a deeper concern: how far can a young player express himself before the weight of regulation stifles his individuality?
Also READ: WWE Legend John Cena surprises fans by posting a picture of Virat Kohli in an iconic pose
Simon Doull provides his unfiltered take on the matter
It was Doull’s impassioned comments on Cricbuzz that brought the debate into the spotlight. Known for his candid takes, Doull didn’t hold back saying, “The team have got to be paying that (the fines). I don’t like it. I love the celebrations; I don’t think he has done anything at all wrong.”
Doull went on to criticize the inconsistency in BCCI’s disciplinary actions, pointing out that senior Indian players have gotten away with far more aggressive or provocative behaviour without so much as a warning. He added, “They are making an example out of a young man who is what, making a note in his notebook?”
His argument touches a nerve that many fans and experts alike feel – the lack of uniformity in enforcing penalties. Celebrations are an integral part of cricket’s modern culture, and when such expressions are stifled selectively, it raises serious questions.
The BCCI has always maintained a strict code of conduct to ensure discipline in the league, but the recurring theme of selective enforcement is impossible to ignore. Rathi’s case appears to exemplify how young or lesser-known players often bear the brunt of regulation, while high-profile names walk away unscathed.
