Table of Contents
The South African cricket team’s triumphant homecoming after clinching the 2025 World Test Championship (WTC) title against Australia was expected to be a celebration of unity and national pride. However, the festivities took an unexpected turn when a press conference comment by pacer Lungi Ngidi reignited the long-standing debate over criticism from former players. Ngidi, addressing the media, dismissed the critiques from ex-Proteas stars as “irrelevant,” sparking a social media storm—one that drew a sharp, witty response from the ever-outspoken Herschelle Gibbs.
Lungi Ngidi’s press room stand and Herschelle Gibbs’ social media retort
The controversy erupted when Ngidi, reflecting on the criticism faced by the current Proteas squad from South African cricket legends, stated, “It’s really irrelevant because at the end of the day, when I am playing, it’s me out there and not them. It is in my sense disappointing because they have been there before and they know how hard it is so, and in that sense it is really disappointing to read things like that but other than that if you are picked to play, you still got a job to do and so you gotta focus on that as the best you can…” This candid response, intended to shut out the noise, instead amplified it, as fans and pundits dissected Ngidi’s words.
Gibbs, known as much for his flamboyant batting as for his unfiltered opinions, was soon tagged by a fan on X with a video of Ngidi’s remarks. True to form, Gibbs didn’t hold back, responding with a pointed “you think I’m really gonna worry about people’s opinion … cry me a river.” The jibe instantly went viral, splitting the cricketing community between those who felt Gibbs was defending the right to critique and others who believed former players should support the new generation.
you think I’m really gonna worry about people’s opinion .. cry me a river 😂😂
— Herschelle Gibbs (@hershybru) June 19, 2025
Also READ: Top 5 oldest captains to win an ICC title ft. Temba Bavuma
Ngidi’s redemption arc in the WTC 2025 final comes in full circle
Ngidi’s comments came in the wake of relentless scrutiny over his form and fitness leading up to the WTC final. Critics, including some ex-players, questioned his place in the side, citing inconsistent performances and injury concerns. But when it mattered most, Ngidi delivered an exceptional performance in the final against Australia, silencing many detractors. His ability to rise under pressure and contribute crucial wickets was instrumental in South Africa’s historic victory, marking their first ICC trophy in 27 years.
The episode has reignited the debate about the role of former players in shaping public opinion and team morale. While Ngidi’s “irrelevant criticism” remark may have been a shield against negativity, Gibbs’ sharp retort reminded everyone that the dialogue between generations—however contentious—remains an integral part of cricket’s evolving narrative.
Also READ: WTC Final 2025: Complete list of winners and the details of prize money
